Radical Muslim cleric linked to many terrorism suspects
POSTED: Thursday, November 19, 2009
WASHINGTON—In nearly a dozen recent terrorism cases in the United States, Britain and Canada, investigators discovered the suspects had something in common: a devotion to the message of Anwar al-Awlaki, an eloquent Muslim cleric who has turned the Web into a tool for extremist indoctrination.
Awlaki, 38, the son of a former agriculture minister and university president in Yemen, has never been accused of planting explosives himself. But experts on terrorism believe his persuasive endorsement of violence as a religious duty, in colloquial, American-accented English, has helped push a series of Western Muslims into terrorism.
Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, the Army psychiatrist charged with of killing 13 people at Fort Hood, Texas, on Nov. 5, is only the latest accused perpetrator or plotter of violence to be linked to the cleric.
In 2006, for example, a group of Canadian Muslims listened to Awlaki's sermons on a laptop a few months before they were charged with plotting major attacks in Ontario, including bombings, shootings, storming the Parliament building and beheading the Canadian prime minister.
In 2007, one of six men later convicted of plotting to attack Fort Dix in New Jersey was picked up on a surveillance tape raving about Awlaki's audio clips. “;You gotta hear this lecture,”; said the plotter, Shain Duka, as he was picked up on a surveillance tape. Duka called the cleric's interpretation of Muslim duties “;the truth, no holes barred, straight how it is!”;
Last year, Awlaki exchanged public letters on the Web with the Somali Islamist group al-Shabaab, which has attracted recruits among young Somali-Americans living in Minnesota. The message from al-Shabaab praised the cleric as “;one of the very few scholars”; who “;defend the honor of the mujahideen.”;
“;Allah knows how many of the brothers and sisters have been affected by your work,”; the open letter said.
Evan Kohlmann, a counterterrorism researcher who has testified in a score of terrorism trials in the United States and United Kingdom, said Awlaki's work has turned up in additional cases in Chicago and Atlanta and in at least seven cases in the United Kingdom.
“;Al-Awlaki condenses the al-Qaida philosophy into digestible, well-written treatises,”; Kohlmann said. “;They may not tell people how to build a bomb or shoot a gun. But he tells them who to kill, and why, and stresses the urgency of the mission.”;
For at least a decade, counterterrorism officials have had a wary eye on Awlaki, an American citizen now living in Yemen. His contacts with three of the future Sept. 11 hijackers, at mosques where he served in San Diego and Falls Church, Va., remain a perplexing mystery about the 2001 terrorist attacks, said Philip Zelikow, who was executive director of the national 9/11 commission.
But in recent years, concerns have focused on Awlaki's influence via his Web site, his Facebook page and many booklets and CDs carrying his message, including a text called “;44 Ways to Support Jihad”; that has raced around the world since it was released in February.
Awlaki's current site, http://www.anwar-alawlaki.com, went offline after he was linked to Hasan, apparently because a series of Web hosting companies took it down. Specialists say it is likely to reappear soon, and indeed, the site's address on Wednesday displayed a Muslim greeting and the promise: “;The Web site will be back to normal with a few days time.”;
Starting late last year, Hasan sought religious advice from the cleric in e-mail messages intercepted by American intelligence. He had seen Awlaki preach at the Virginia mosque in 2001.
In July, the month Hasan was transferred to Fort Hood, Awlaki posted a blistering attack on his Web site lambasting Muslim soldiers who would fight against other Muslims, a conflict that preoccupied Hasan, who was facing deployment to Afghanistan.
“;What kind of twisted fight is this?”; Awlaki wrote on “;Imam Anwar's Blog.”; A Muslim soldier who follows orders to kill Muslims, he wrote, “;is a heartless beast, bent of evil, who sells his religion for a few dollars.”;
After the Fort Hood shootings, Awlaki wrote a blog posting calling Hasan a hero. “;The only way a Muslim could Islamically justify serving as a soldier in the U.S. Army,”; he wrote, “;is if his intention is to follow the footsteps of men like Nidal.”;
The question of what to do about terror propagandists like Awlaki is complex. His writings, though they encourage violence, are protected by the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech, legal authorities say.
Moreover, even as they fuel extremism, Web sites like his can be a valuable counterterrorist tool, because intelligence analysts use them to track those who, like Hasan, visit a site, post comments or send e-mail messages to its creators.
“;The debate has gone on for a long time: take these sites down or leave them up to gather information,”; said Brian Fishman, a consultant to several government agencies on terrorism.
Awlaki was born in New Mexico in 1971, where his father, Nasser al-Awlaki, was studying agricultural economics. After studying Islam in Yemen, Anwar, too, pursued an American education, earning a bachelor's degree in civil engineering from Colorado State and a master's in education at San Diego State. While in San Diego, he was arrested for soliciting prostitutes, according to law enforcement records.
At a San Diego mosque where he served as an imam, Awlaki encountered two future hijackers, Khalid al-Midhar and Nawaf al-Hazmi. In early 2001, Awlaki moved to the Virginia mosque, attended by Hazmi and a third hijacker, Hani Hanjour.
The 9/11 commission described the connection as suspicious. Law enforcement officials say they strongly doubted Awlaki knew of the plot, though they could not prove it.
While in the United States, Awlaki presented a moderate public face. A month after 9/11, as the imam at Dar al-Hijrah mosque in Virginia, he told The New York Times that he would no longer tolerate “;inflammatory”; rhetoric. The article said Awlaki “;is held up as a new generation of Muslim leader capable of merging East and West.”;
Imam Johari Abdul-Malik, who currently serves at the Virginia mosque, said that description rang true to him at the time. Awlaki's sermons were accessible, often witty explorations of passages from the Quran.
“;We could have all been duped,”; he said. “;But I think something happened to him, and he changed his views.”;
One thing that happened, after he left the United States in 2002 for London and then Yemen, was eighteen months in a Yemeni prison. He has publicly blamed the United States for pressuring Yemeni authorities to keep him locked up and said he was questioned by FBI agents while imprisoned.
Since his release in December 2007 his message has been even more overtly supportive of violence. In “;44 Ways to Support Jihad,”; he showed a wry awareness of intelligence agencies' interest in him and his writings.
“;The only ones who are spending the money and time translating Jihad literature are the Western intelligence services,”; he wrote, addressing English speakers who cannot read Arabic, “;and too bad, they would not be willing to share it with you.”;