Backers of new Maui hospital point to perils of earthquakes
The recent events demonstrate a need for additional health services, a lawyer says
By Tara Godvin
Associated Press
Those behind a proposed new hospital on Maui are appealing a state decision to reject the new facility -- citing Sunday's earthquakes as evidence of why the island needs another hospital.
Malulani Health and Medical Center, a planned 150-bed acute-care community hospital in Kihei, filed its appeal of the decision last Monday.
Dr. Ron Kwon, Malulani's president, said Thursday that the center had already planned to file its appeal when the quakes hit.
Two state advisory panels voted against the medical center, while one panel was in favor of it. The final decision was made earlier this month by Dr. David Sakamoto, head of the State Health Planning and Development Agency.
Opponents of the plan said they were not convinced the island needed a hospital other than the Maui Memorial Medical Center, the only existing acute-care medical facility on the island.
In the appeal, Malulani attorney Phillip Moon said the earthquakes demonstrated "significant factors and circumstances for the need for additional medical facilities on Maui."
Malulani also said that the process for making the decision was flawed.
The aftermath of the quakes off the Big Island -- including the evacuation of several Kona Community Hospital patients to Hilo -- simply reinforced belief that another hospital is needed on Maui, he said.
"Now what do you do if you only have one hospital? Where do the patients go? I mean, you can't just put them in a car, can you? That's the problem, we're islands," he said.
Gov. Linda Lingle, who was Maui's mayor for eight years and a member of the Maui County Council for a decade, has been a strong supporter of the planned facility and has warned that the state might not have the money to fund future upgrades at state-subsidized Maui Memorial.
A committee of five health-care industry experts, which includes Sakamoto and a Maui County health-care panel representative, will now need to decide within 30 days if Malulani's request has merit.
If so, the committee must hold a public hearing within 30 days of the appeal and then issue its final decision within the following 45 days.